Thatcher

Margaret ThatcherHaving regretted that I haven’t written enough of my ‘brief lives’ posts last week, along comes another one with the death of Margaret Thatcher.

Of course the are those who would say that her life wasn’t brief enough – ‘Finally I get to wear my black suit and tap shoes together’ tweeted Frankie Boyle.

There were similar sentiments from the unreconstructed likes of Ken Livingstone, Derek Hatton, Gerry Adams and George Galloway. Even that political heavyweight, Joey Barton, has jumped on the bandwagon.

And there was dancing in the streets of Brixton, Glasgow, Belfast and Grimethorpe, and a celebratory riot in Bristol, while a tweet from the Crouch End branch in north London read: ‘If for any reason, anyone feels like celebrating anything we have Taittinger available at £10 less than usual at £29.  Just saying …’

Hardly a nation united in grief I think you’d say. Personally, I don’t find myself spitting vitriol, but I’m not donning my mourning weeds either.

It’s true that she brought about a seismic shift in Britain, but she could only destroy and had no vision of what to put in its place. We pay the price still.

She encouraged home ownership by selling off social housing that wasn’t replaced, hence the bedroom tax debacle today. She encouraged deregulation and speculation that ultimately led to the banking crisis and she sold off inefficient state run utilities to carpetbagging companies that do an equally inefficient job but at a higher cost to the public.

Perhaps her greatest achievement was to become our first woman prime minister and you can gauge its success because we haven’t bothered to repeat the experiment.

I could go on about the other things she did, particularly to the NHS, but there are enough people speaking ill of the dead.

What hasn’t been mentioned though is her introduction of spin politics to the UK, or rather the way that the spin doctors became public figures in their own right.

I’m speaking of Bernard Ingham, of course, that great bully and manipulator of the media.

My abiding memory of him comes from the summer of 1985 and the terrible disaster at Manchester Airport when a Boeing 747 caught fire killing 54 people.

I’d been drafted in to help deal with the media scrum at Wythenshawe Hospital where many of the injured were taken and it was absolute bedlam. (I still can’t figure out how the Chicago Tribune got there before I did.)

Thatcher visited the following day, I suspect because she was genuinely sympathetic, but I’m also sure that Ingham saw it as a wonderful media opportunity.

It was the closest I ever got to her along with dozens of hacks. Among them was a much respected reporter from the local BBC who tried to get a word with the PM as she walked towards the hospital doors. Ingham objected and literally barged her to the ground, despite the fact that the reporter was heavily pregnant at the time.

I’ve always likened spin doctoring to a martial art that has evolved over the years. Today it is like fencing with a rapier, looking for an opening and weakness to exploit. Before that it was more akin to the precision of karate, and even earlier like judo, using the weight of your opponent to defeat themself.

But Ingham was the original and for him, spin doctoring was bare knuckle cage fighting and we have him and Thatcher to thank for the way that spin has become an end in itself.

Nobody’s prefect. If you find any spelling mistakes or other errors in this post, please let me know by highlighting the text and pressing Ctrl+Enter.

4 comments… Add yours
  • Roger Green 9th April 2013

    I have mixed to negative feelings myself. I REALLY was looking forward to your take; thanks!

    Reply
    • Mr Parrot 9th April 2013

      Thanks Roger. I still feel I should have written a more thoughtful piece. Perhaps I will in time.

      Reply
  • Trevor Rowley 9th April 2013

    It was inevitable that there would be so much ill-feeling expressed about her once her death came about (we had a foretaste whenever her ill health was reported on during the last decade) but to reduce this ill-feeling to bile is, in my opinion, shameful. Whatever she did, I feel sure she believed she was doing it for the good of the country. Unfortunately, her image grated with most people; from the cultivated, pompous voice that just reeked of “I know better than you” to the handbag clutching, blue rinse uniform of twin set and pearls. In many ways, she just couldn’t win. If she’d given money away in the streets she’d have been condemned as a “litter lout” at best or a looney at worst. Tell you what, we certainly aren’t going to mourn the likes of sharp-suited, scouse wide boy, Derek Hatton, when he goes and I have grave doubts about George Galloway’s reason for being on God’s earth. As for Joy Barton, “thicko” is about the only way you could describe him. Three dailies today described her as having “divided” the nation, “changed” the nation and having “saved” the nation. She certainly made people sit up and take notice.

    Reply
    • Mr Parrot 9th April 2013

      She was certainly a conviction politician as has been widely observed. My doubts are more to do with whether she actually achieved what she set out to achieve or if there were unintended, yet foreseeable consequences as I hinted at above. The housing crisis is the most obvious example and the ‘fix’ of the bedroom tax is straight out of the Thatcher textbook.

      But I do agree that some of the comments have been unseemly, especially after so long. I suppose it illustrates that there was no lack of opinion as far as she was concerned – it was either love her or loathe her.

      Reply

(will not be published)

Scroll Up

Thanks for taking time to send this report

The following text will be sent to me: