Fair Play

I’ve said this before, and no doubt I will say it again, but the play-off finals to decide who gets promotion in the football leagues is a bloody stupid idea and very unfair on the teams who lose out, even though they got more points than the eventual ‘winner’ over season.

Take this weekend’s games: Southend who finished fourth, two pointa behind third placed Swansea, beat sixth placed Lincoln City on Saturday; yesterday, fifth placed Sheffield Wednesday, who finished seven points behind third placed Tramere Rovers, beat sixth placed Hartlepool; and the pattern will contue today as Preston take on West Ham who finished 10 and 12 points behind third placed Ipswich.

“Everyone knew the rules at the start of the season,” is the usual mantra, but that doesn’t stop the rules being bloody stupid. And it doesn’t do the fifth or sixth placed ‘victors’ any favours either. If they’re not good enough to get in the top three then they’re probably not good enough to survive in a higher league, witness Crystal Palace.

But since the match is happening, I wish Preston well, not just because they’re a Lancashire team, but for Tom Finney’s sake. I met him when he was in his 60s and chairman of Preston Health Authority. A nicer bloke you couldn’t hope to wish to meet, so c’mon you North Enders.

UPDATE: 1800 — Preston 0 – West Ham 1. Ah well, it wasn’t to be. Preston played well and just the dodgy Millennium Stadium pitch that made Claude Davis to slip at the vital moment when he looked to be headibg the cross clear and Bobby Zamora nipped in.and scored. I thought that Youl Mawene looked good at right back for the Enders.

Nobody’s prefect. If you find any spelling mistakes or other errors in this post, please let me know by highlighting the text and pressing Ctrl+Enter.

4 comments… Add yours
  • Steve 30th May 2005

    Must admit I was rooting for the whites even though they did sell us John Macken for £5million.

    But there you go, the kiss 'o death that's me.

  • Mosher 31st May 2005

    I'm no use, either. Was was rooting for Preston (first football league winners… and also easier to get to for an away game) and Hartlepool (North East connection). So my fault. Sorry.

    And I agree. Bloody stupid rule.

    I'm really curious to know, though… out of all the lower divisions, how many times has the team finishing third made it through the playoff to take the place they should have had? I bet it's a remarkably small number.

    Mind, it could be worse. You could have a playoff at the end of the season between the top few teams in the Prem so see who actually wins it.

    Nah. That's TOO stupid. Who on earth would even consider using such a ludicrous method to determine a league trophy…?

  • Shooting Parrots 1st June 2005

    If it was such a good idea, why not 3 to 10 in the Premiership play-off for the last two Champs (huh?) League places?

  • Shooting Parrots 1st June 2005

    I should have said that this plan could be good news for Man C, so I think Mike would go for it. Who knows, perhaps a back door for Liverpool.


Your email will not be published on this site, but note that this and any other personal data you choose to share is stored here. Please see the Privacy Policy for more information.

Spelling error report

The following text will be sent to our editors: