Crusading Atheism

I’ve no idea whether Pope Benedict was or wasn’t a member of the Nazi Youth when he was growing up in Germany. It would come as no surprise given the times and the world he was living in. But if he was, does that make him unfit to be Pope as some people claim?

My understanding of Christian philosophy is that the repenting sinner has greater spiritual worth than someone who has shown piety all their life. Welcome home the prodigal and all that.

Perhaps Joseph Ratzinger’s critics should examine their resentments, just as the dutiful son had to as he slaughtered the fatted calf, another who didn’t rejoice at the prodigal’s return.

Then there were the comment by Cardinal Casper that Britain harbours aggressive atheism that got Stephen Fry and others hot under the collar, but then seemed to prove his point by being aggressively atheistic.

Britain is certainly a secular society, but the militant atheists are very much in the minority. The majority have no view one way or the other and that is what hurts the church the most, the couldn’t care less agnosticism. At least they can have a good row with the dissenters.

But the most fatuous comment came from Birkbeck College’s professor of philosophy, A C Rayling:

The Vatican is no state. It is a garden in Rome with buildings on it. But if you and I set up the Church of the Fairies of the Garden, then I don’t think we should automatically be meeting the Queen, be entitled to seats in the House of Lords or get money for our fairy schools. If we shouldn’t have these rights, then I don’t think that the men in skirts should have them.

Hmm. If the Church of the Fairies had a 2,000 year history, a billion plus followers worldwide and the power to upset Stephen Fry simply by existing, I think they too would expect to be taken seriously in the world.

For the record, I call myself an atheist, but have no problem with the Pope’s visit if it makes people happy. And while Dawkins and Hawking make for interesting reading, by its own logic, science cannot prove that God doesn’t exist because you can’t prove a negative.

But if He did, He might clarify a few things.

Nobody’s prefect. If you find any spelling mistakes or other errors in this post, please let me know by highlighting the text and pressing Ctrl+Enter.

2 comments… Add yours
  • Yorkshire Pudding 17th September 2010

    I am one of the minority of militant atheists you speak of. I abhor all religions. They belong back in the middle ages where they were developed by cynical controlling forces. Loving one’s fellow man and seeking to do good in this world can happen without ludicrous back-up stories. Religion clouds vision and stops us from being who we really are. Screw “The Pope” – the sooner he’s back in the Vatican with his fawning cronies the better. Sitting in his comical “Popemobile”, he looks for all the world like an ice-cream salesman. The trouble is that his ice-cream is poisonous.

  • Polly 17th September 2010

    I believe you’re right about the Catholic church, but there are a billion people around the world who say we’re wrong. Religion in all its forms has generally espoused a peaceful philosophy, at least as far as individuals are concerned — it has been a different matter as far as kings, governments and other leaders are concerned — and I sometimes wonder what might have become of civilization without it. The quesion is, how do we make the transition from superstitious puppets to free-thinking individuals without losing the do unto others philosophy of religion.


Your email will not be published on this site, but note that this and any other personal data you choose to share is stored here. Please see the Privacy Policy for more information.

Spelling error report

The following text will be sent to our editors: