N is for Nicolas Notovitch

This is my contribution to Round Thirteen of ABC Wednesday. I am focusing on people for the fourth time, some famous, some infamous and some half-forgotten, although I am worried that I may have exhausted some letters of the alphabet, but I’ll see how it goes!

Nicolas NotovitchOne of the essential elements of a successful hoax, apart from a credulous public, is to create a story that just might be true.

In 1894, the Russian journalist Nicolas Notovitch published La vie inconnue de Jesus Christ which purported to reveal that Jesus has spent many years as both teacher and scholar at a Tibetan Buddhist monastery.

Notovitch had been travelling in India as the correspondent for the Russian journal, Novaya Vremiya (New Times) in the winter of 1887. While in the Kashmir region he fell from his horse and broke his leg and was taken to the Hemis Gompa monastery for treatment.

He was given excellent care and was told that this was because the lamas believed he shared the same faith. When he protested that he was a Christian, they explained that Issa, the greatest of the Buddhist prophets, had also founded the Christian religion.

The lamas produced two bound volumes, part of a collection of ancient Tibetan records written in Pali, an old Indian language, in the first two centuries AD.

They told how Issa had been born in Israel and that he had arrived in India when he was fourteen years old with a group of merchants. He travelled the sub-continent for the next fifteen years learning the tenets of Buddhism and gaining a reputation as a preacher and prophet.

It was an intriguing tale and Notovitch made the obvious connection between Issa and Jesus. Both shared a pacifist philosophy, but more importantly, it explained the gap in Biblical records which shows Jesus in the Temple at the age of thirteen, then nothing until he was thirty.

Hemis Monastery

Hemis Monastery

Notovitch made notes as best he could and took his discovery to the church when he returned to Europe, but rather than being treated as a bearer of glad tidings, he was warned that he should not attempt to publish his findings.

As mentioned above, Notovitch chose to ignore these warnings and published them as The Secret Life of Jesus Christ and this led to his arrest in St Petersburg on charges of ‘literary activity dangerous to the state and to society’. He was imprisoned in the Peter and Paul Fortress and then exiled to Siberia, although he was allowed to return in 1897.

So does Notovitch’s story hold up? Scholars at the time though not after seeking confirmation from the monastery. The head lama said there had been no western visitors in the previous fifteen years, nor was there any documents like the one described. Notovitch defended his claims but was eventually forced to admit that he had fabricated the tale.

But had he? There are certainly those who believe that Notovitch really had visited the monastery and that later visitors have been told similar accounts of the life of Jesus in India and that the church is suppressing the truth.

You pays your money, you takes your choice and The Unknown Life of Jesus Christ is available on Amazon, complete with The Life of Saint Issa.

Nobody’s prefect. If you find any spelling mistakes or other errors in this post, please let me know by highlighting the text and pressing Ctrl+Enter.

1 comment… Add yours
  • Roger Green 16th October 2013

    I’ve LONG thought that Jesus had to have gone SOMEWHERE between the time he was 12 and 30, and India seems as plausible as anywhere.


Your email will not be published on this site, but note that this and any other personal data you choose to share is stored here. Please see the Privacy Policy for more information.

Spelling error report

The following text will be sent to our editors: